Legacy of Shame and the Addictive Process. Claudia Black
CENTRAL RECOVERY PRESS
Central Recovery Press (CRP) is committed to publishing exceptional materials addressing addiction treatment, recovery, and behavioral health care topics, including original and quality books, audio/visual communications, and web-based new media. Through a diverse selection of titles, we seek to contribute a broad range of unique resources for professionals, recovering individuals and their families, and the general public.
For more information, visit www.centralrecoverypress.com.
Central Recovery Press, Las Vegas, NV 89129
© 2011 by Claudia Black
All rights reserved. Published 2011.
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the written permission of the publisher.
Publisher: Central Recovery Press
3321 N. Buffalo Drive
Las Vegas, NV 89129
17 16 15 14 13 12 11 1 2 3 4 5
ISBN-13: 978-1-936290-67-3 (e-book)
Author Note: This book is derived from a presentation given to helping professionals at an addiction conference in early 2011. What I share with the professionals is not to be a mystery as it is important for you, the reader, to understand as well.
While I periodically make a statement directly to the clinical audience, this e-book adaptation of the presentation is designed for the general public. Though it has been edited for style and content and modified for this format, I trust you will hear my voice.
April 2011
Claudia Black
Central Recovery Press offers a diverse selection of titles focused on addiction, recovery, and behavioral health. Our books represent the experiences and opinions of their authors only. Every effort has been made to ensure that events, institutions, and statistics presented in our books as facts are accurate and up-to-date. The opinions expressed are those of the authors only.
Table of Contents
Types of Abandonment
Physical
Sexual
Emotional
Disconnection Strategies & Trauma Responses
Recognizing Shame Screens
Control
Rage
Victim Role
Depression
Perfectionism/Procrastination
Addictive Disorder
Suicide
Cultural Considerations
Letting Go of Shame & Moving Forward
Legacy of Shame and the Addictive Process
When I think about shame in the addictive process, I’m often reminded just how common it is. A high percentage of the people I’ve worked with struggle in this area. I’m not sure that any therapists in the addiction treatment field works with anyone who isn’t struggling with shame to one degree or another.
When I think about shame in the addictive process, I think about clients such as James (please note that any names I use throughout this presentation have been changed). James, who is from the Midwest and was in an addiction treatment program, said something to me that I thought was very poignant, “I think the shame that I feel over my own addiction is really nothing but a refinement and purification of the shame I felt as a child because of my father’s addiction. On an emotional level, I have drunken liquor that has been twice brewed. To think that I could end up like my father; to think that my disease would impact my children as his disease impacted me has been a prospect far too horrible for me to even begin to want to comprehend.”
He went on to say “this was the wrong meal of shame that I milled and that I baked into a very fine pastry. I spent so many years trying not to recognize what it is that my father and I had in common. We did things really differently. He did all of his drinking outside the home, and I did so much of my drinking and using within the home. He did a lot of crying and was very open with his tears, and I worked very hard so people would never see my tears. I can remember over the years though, he didn’t get help. I remember him pleading and crying for help. I understand today that superficially we were very different, but underneath we truly had the same disease.”
Another client, Cindy, was raised with two addictive parents and was married to an addict—her husband was in jail for a felony drinking and driving charge. She told me, “You know, as a kid, all I ever wanted was to do it differently than how it was when I was growing up. Here I am just a couple of days away from my twenty-third birthday, my husband is in jail for a felony drinking and driving charge, and I’m looking into the eyes of my baby who is thirteen months old whom I’d just thrown across the living room floor. It was at that moment that my world and sanity absolutely crumbled. I was clearly doing it exactly as my parents had done it.”
However, from that moment, some wonderful things would happen very quickly for Cindy. It was that realization that compelled her to reach out to a local community mental health center and in that local community mental health center she was referred to a psychologist who quickly said to her, “I believe I understand why this is happening to you, and I believe that I can help you,” and then he talked with her about her willingness to come back and see him on a regular basis. But he would also introduce her for the first time to a twelve-step program, and that’s where she would find her recovery—both from the community mental health center and that twelve-step program. When her husband came out of jail, he would begin his own recovery process, and I think this was propelled not just by his experience in jail, but by the fact that his wife had reached out for and gotten help. He could see the difference it made in her life.
Then there is the sixteen-year old who said to me, “You know, I was probably in first grade before I ever understood that ‘worthless’ was not my first name. I really thought it was my first name. It was the only thing my parents ever called me.” And she said, “I had a middle name. You want to know what my middle name was. If I wasn’t worthless, then I was simply called ‘stupid.’” Sadly, that is the legacy that keeps on going. Those are the legacies of internalized shame.
In Care of the Soul (1992), Thomas Moore wrote of how the sentimental image of the family that we present publicly is really a defense for the pain of proclaiming family for what it is: a sometimes comforting, but often times absolutely devastating task of life and memory. To deny or to disown any part of our experience is going to leave us dangerously incomplete and vulnerable to our shame.
For people struggling with shame one of the healthiest things they can do is to name their reality—to name the shame-based messages that they have internalized and that they continue to operate from today, in order for them to become separate from that shame. When I talk about shame, I’m referring to toxic shame—an internalized belief system that says there is something inherently wrong with who they are. Many people think of shame as a feeling. I actually believe the more you come to believe that who you are is not okay, the more disconnected you are from your emotional self. So I think of shame