Другая невидимая рука. Предоставление общественных услуг на основе выбора и конкуренции. Джулиан Ле Гранд

Другая невидимая рука. Предоставление общественных услуг на основе выбора и конкуренции - Джулиан Ле Гранд


Скачать книгу
альтруистическое? Действительно, есть и более обширная проблема: может ли хоть какая-то форма поведения быть мотивирована истинным альтруизмом, поскольку даже в том случае, когда люди поступают альтруистически, они, вероятно, делают это, поскольку хотят этого, и только поэтому их поведение приносит другим какую-то пользу. Решение этой проблемы выходит за пределы данного исследования; в более развернутой форме я обсуждал ее в своей предыдущей работе: Le Grand 2003, p. 27–28.

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
Скачать книгу