Global Residence and Citizenship Handbook. Christian H. Kälin
returns to the same country. Complicated and costly arguments can emerge with the tax authorities, during which the taxpayer often loses. Even if the facts are quite clear and in favor of the tax payer, and a tax lawyer may insist that they have a “good case”, tax authorities, once on the case, often win simply because if it goes to court, in most cases the courts rule in their favor. With tax authorities in high-tax countries coming under increased pressure to collect more revenue, it is likely that they will scrutinize even more carefully in cases worth their while.
For wealthy individuals moving their tax residence from one country to another, it is extremely important to plan a move carefully, and to anticipate possible issues later on depending on what the intention is in a few years’ time. It is also critical that all laws and regulations are carefully observed, and that one’s life can really be organized around those rules without it being uncomfortable and impairing the quality of life.
Besides tax residence, of course, other factors such as the impact on your matrimonial property regime, or inheritance law applicable if you pass away, are important. Here, if habitual residence were the sole connecting factor, your matrimonial, property and inheritance rights would be subject only to the legal system of the country where you happen to be resident. In many instances, however, this is not the case: matrimonial property regimes may remain the same, either by law or by express choice (for example by a notarized marriage contract concluded between the spouses in order to establish the law applicable on their marriage and in particular their matrimonial property regime).
Due to the significant impact on a person’s estate, it is essential to determine one’s domicile, especially if the person is effectively connected to and resides in more than one country. Moreover, each country has its own tax laws and regulations which will establish the tax liability if considered a tax resident. Therefore when a person wishes to change tax residence status, it is important to ascertain what will constitute domicile or habitual residence in the eyes of the particular jurisdiction.
Factors to take into consideration may include the number of days spent in the country, the location of the main family home, family and business connections, and nationality.
In some countries, having accommodation available for use in that country after moving abroad may deem you resident in that country. It is generally advisable not to have accommodation readily available in such jurisdictions, which include countries like Germany, Sweden and many others.
Tax liability always arises with the number of days spent in the jurisdiction i.e. 183 days a year or more spent in the UK makes a person resident for the purpose of tax. But very often, a much smaller number of days is sufficient (in Switzerland for example, if you spend more than 30 days in a year and are deemed to pursue an economic activity, you are considered resident for tax purposes unless a tax treaty applies and provides otherwise).
Small efforts such as cancelling licenses and memberships; amending the electoral register to show that one is voting abroad; transferring the main bank account outside the country; and moving any business operation out of the country will show the local authorities that the person has no intention of being resident in the country.
In the end, it is a combination of several hard factors (such as number of days spent in a country, availability of accommodation, etc.) and soft factors (memberships in clubs, social and business connections and activities) which will determine the successful outcome of your international residence planning. This can range from very clear situations where all relevant hard and soft factors are in your favor, to borderline situations with a considerable risk of being deemed tax resident in more than one country and having to engage in lengthy discussions and arguments with tax authorities in one or several countries.
1.4 Factors to consider when choosing a new residence
The decision to move to another country must not be taken lightly as there are many factors that will affect an individual and his family. It is recommended to undergo a thorough analysis of the country that you may consider as your new main place of residence and possibly your new domicile of choice.
There are significant aspects such as business environment and tax that must be considered but there are also seemingly minor aspects that one initially does not pay any attention to which may later become a source of discontent. It is important to distinguish between temporary stays such as vacationing in a country, visiting on business - and actually living there. Temporary visits can give a skewed perspective on a place. Each individual will have their own particular reason for changing residence; however, it is important to be mindful of the potential pitfalls when making the decision to change your residence and establish a new main base in your life.
Obtaining an alternative residence is a significant, very personal and multifaceted decision for any individual. Whilst this decision may have a direct impact on the applicant’s personal situation and business interests, a range of social, political, economic and family issues should also be considered to determine the best jurisdiction in which to reside or hold a residence permit for reasons of security or personal flexibility. Therefore it is important to understand the advantages of different options and how they best serve your needs. Some important criteria to consider when looking at an alternative country of residence include its geographical location and access via air, road, rail and sea; its political and economic stability as well as the stability of the region in which it is situated; its banking facilities and business environment; its legal system; its tax system and any double taxation treaties with your country of origin; if you are married or live with a partner, the implications for any (pre-) nuptial agreements or other arrangements and the impact on your matrimonial property regime; if you have school-age children, the education system and availability of private schools; visa-free travel possibilities as a residence permit holder; residence and other requirements for obtaining citizenship; and of course the overall cost of obtaining and maintaining a residence permit.
There are many different aspects which are relevant to consider. The following gives an overview of the most important of these aspects.
Personal situation
It is essential that your tax and estate planning follows your personal and business situation, and not vice-versa. You should never relocate mainly for tax reasons. Unless you are happy in the new environment from a personal, family and lifestyle point of view, experience shows that very often you would then act in a way that will sooner or later jeopardize the tax planning which made you change your residence in the first place. Nevertheless, there are many situations where a change of residence fits in well with an individual’s personal, family or business situation, and in these cases a change of residence becomes a key element of international tax and estate planning. Indeed, the mobility made possible by modern technologies, logistics and efficient transport links means that persons of talent and wealth have an increased range of options with regard to where to reside and from where to conduct their business.
Education and schooling
An important such personal aspect is the schooling of children. If you have children of school age, careful planning is required when you consider relocating to a new country. Besides the obvious priorities of whether the school environment is right for the child, language barriers, education systems, and a general idea about the education options available in the country need to be weighed up.
It can be traumatic for a child to move to a new country where everything is unfamiliar. Therefore it is paramount that one considers the education choices carefully.
International schools can be a good option as the curriculum is usually in English and based on an international standard, recognized worldwide. Children will often be integrated more easily as the school is geared towards foreigners. The downside is that your children will not integrate with the locals as much.
An alternative is to send your children to a boarding school in a country with exceptional educational institutions such as Switzerland, England or the US.
As each child will have different academic needs, the choice of school is a personal decision but it is important to consider the language and the credentials of the school. Is the curriculum recognized by international universities? Will the child easily adapt to the environment?
It