Toronto Local History 3-Book Bundle. Scott Kennedy
early days are cloaked in mystery, owing to the destruction of many records around the time of the Revolutionary War in the United States, but it seems he was born in New Hampshire to Irish immigrant parents, on August 10, 1765. Mozart was nine years old and had already spent over three years performing in the palaces and concert halls of Europe. Joseph Shepard — while precocious in his own way — would prove a much later bloomer. In 1774, when Beethoven was turning four, the Shepards moved to Upper Canada, apparently settling in the Bay of Quinte area. They were Loyalists and likely felt uncomfortable living south of the border, as the potential of armed conflict with Britain became ever more likely.
Sporadic mentions of Joseph appear during the late 1700s, but it’s hard to know who to believe. The Globe newspaper of April 26, 1899, reported that he came to North York in 1785 to travel with Native traders, as he had done in the Quinte area. This seems quite likely, as Joseph would be twenty years old by then, and practised in the physical challenges that travelling with Natives on their trading routes demanded. The next we hear of Joseph is that he apparently applied for and received a land grant in Kingston in 1790 that he did not accept. His permanent relationship with North York would begin three years later.
By 1793, Joseph Shepard was helping the very first white settlers in the area to erect their initial primitive log cabins. In 1798, after helping the others with their shanties, Joseph built his own cabin on the northwest corner of present-day Yonge and Sheppard. In 1802, he bought the lot where his cabin stood from a William Dickson, who had acquired this Lot 16-1W (on the north side of Sheppard, running west from Yonge Street to Bathurst) in 1798, a year after it had been granted to James Johnson. It was still mostly forest when Joseph purchased it.
On April 11, 1803, Joseph married Catherine Fisher, a member of the Pennsylvania German family, led by patriarch Jacob Fisher, who had come to Upper Canada in 1796 and settled near what today is Dufferin and Steeles after receiving a land grant from the Crown. The Fishers were accompanied on their move by Jacob Kummer (later to become Cummer), who had married Catherine’s sister, Elizabeth, when the families lived in Pennsylvania. The Fisher family farmed, constructed mills, opened a blacksmith shop, and soon a little village named Fisherville was born at the crossroads. The Fisherville Presbyterian Church, constructed in 1856, was moved to Black Creek Pioneer Village in 1960, where it can still receive visitors.
At present-day Yonge and Sheppard, Joseph and Catherine were wasting little time starting their family. Their first child, Thomas, was born in 1804, followed by three other sons and four daughters. In 1805, Joseph applied for and was granted the deed to Lot 17-1W, directly north of the family’s first farm, giving them all a little something to look forward to and some room to grow.
The Shepards’ days were now defined by hard labour and incremental progress — clearing land, burning the stumps, selling the potash, planting whatever they could, raising some livestock, raising a family, and making their cabin more comfortable. The latter two responsibilities would have fallen almost exclusively to Catherine. Joseph, still as involved and gregarious as ever, somehow found time to serve York Township in a number of appointed and elected positions. Beginning in 1804, he was township assessor for three terms and pound-keeper for two, which, in those days, included more lost and errant horses, swine, and cattle than cats and dogs. He was also elected overseer of highways and fence-viewer.
Both these latter positions had the potential to put Joseph in frequent conflict with his neighbours. As an overseer of highways, he had to make sure that the settlers were clearing the road allowances around their farms as per the conditions of their Crown land grant applications and take action if they were negligent. As a fence-viewer, he was obliged to settle disputes among neighbouring farmers with respect to livestock caught wandering onto other peoples’ farms. At the time, hogs and cattle were marked for identification, but allowed to graze at large in the country. When they were caught “trespassing” on fenced land, they were impounded by the landowner and the fence viewer was called in to make sure that the fences on the property met the township specifications that had been designed to keep the wandering livestock out. As can be imagined, this would have sparked many a heated argument that Joseph would have had to settle in such a way that all parties, Joseph included, would be able to continue living as neighbours on good terms.
In 1807, Joseph took his political involvement to the next level when he allied himself with the fledgling reform movement in Upper Canada, which was beginning to speak out against injustices the farmers believed themselves to be suffering at the hands of the ruling Family Compact. The farmers felt that the Family Compact, who controlled the government through their closed network of entitled families, were guilty of corruption, land speculation, religious favouritism, and administrative extravagance. That year, Joseph chaired meetings to support Robert Thorpe, a judge of the Court of the King’s Bench in Upper Canada, in his campaign to make the Family Compact more accountable. Though the reform movement wasn’t really organized until the 1820s, Joseph stood for election to Upper Canada’s lower house, running on a reform platform. A split in the reform vote led to his defeat by the government candidate, Thomas Ridout, who had already served as sergeant-at-arms to the House of the Assembly and clerk of the peace for the Home District.
To some, Joseph Shepard was an unlikely reformer since he was a supporter of the Church of England (Anglican), an allegiance usually accompanied by Loyalist tendencies, and, in fact, he did fight with the British troops in the War of 1812 as a forty-seven-year-old private in the 3rd York Militia. He was seriously wounded at the Battle of York in April 1813 when the powder magazine at Fork York was intentionally blown up to prevent it from falling into the hands of the American invaders. Catherine found him the next morning, unconscious and lying in his own dried blood. His injuries, including broken ribs and a mangled left thigh, were serious enough to warrant a lifetime pension. In addition, he was given one hundred acres in Tecumseth Township in Simcoe County in appreciation for his service.
Meanwhile, back on the farm, the Shepards’ four hundred acres were becoming more productive every year. As more land was cleared, more crops were planted, more livestock was introduced, and orchards began to bear fruit. The farm was becoming quite a profitable enterprise. By all accounts, Joseph was a man with a social conscience who believed in sharing any good fortune that might come his way, a trait he may well have absorbed from the Natives he travelled with in his youth, who believed in re-paying kindness with kindness. In keeping with Joseph’s values, he and Catherine gifted the community with a parcel of land that continues to benefit local residents to this day when they bought two-and-three-quarters acres of tableland on the east side of Yonge Street, half-a-mile north of York Mills, and donated the land for the construction of the new St. John’s Anglican Church. Joseph himself worked alongside other members of the congregation, felling the virgin timber on site and squaring the logs with axe and adze.
In the 1820s, Joseph built a sawmill and a gristmill on the West Don River that ran through the western portion of his farm near Bathurst Street, in an area that came to be known as Chuckle Hollow. The mills were run by his sons, and, like most mills in pioneer North York, they were very profitable enterprises. Joseph remained committed to the reform movement and especially to its leader, William Lyon Mackenzie, whom he had supported in Upper Canada’s election of 1832. Two years later, the Town of York reverted to its original First Nations’ name of “Toronto,” and Mackenzie was elected the town’s first mayor. This was also the year that the Shepards would really start to spread their wings.
In 1834, Joseph and Catherine’s two eldest sons bought farms of their own in the second concession west of Yonge Street. Thomas, now thirty years old, bought Lot 18-2W, which ran east from Bathurst Street to Dufferin Street, about halfway between Sheppard and Finch. The eastern portion of his farm included the majestic sweep of the West Don Valley where the Holocaust Education and Memorial Centre of Toronto stand today, just north of Bathurst and Sheppard. Jacob, a couple of years younger than Thomas, bought Lot 19-2W, directly to the north of his brother’s farm. Both sons built new mills on the West Don River and got down to the serious business of building their own farms. Back on the original farm at Yonge and Sheppard, Joseph and Catherine were about to start construction of a house to replace their log cabin — a house that is still a home today, on its original foundation, over 175 years later.
Joseph was now nearly seventy years old, but he still had his