Cincinnati Haunted Handbook. Jeff Morris
these are ghostly remnants of the dark rituals that are rumored to have gone on or if rituals still go on here.
The spot that is reputed to be the most evil is within Reily Cemetery—a stone monument that is shaped like an angel. For some reason, the arms of the angel have been removed. People feel most uncomfortable near this angel and some suggest that the statue is possessed by some sort of demonic entity.
visiting
It is a terrible idea to enter any Reily Cemetery at night. First of all, the cemeteries all close at night, and this is clearly posted on signs. Local sheriffs know the rumors that these places are haunted, and they know that thrill seekers will attempt to enter the cemeteries after closing time. If you try to get in, you will probably be caught. The Indian Creek Church Burial Ground actually has two gates that you need to pass through to access the cemetery, each posted with warnings that they will prosecute to the fullest extent of the law if you pass these gates.
Many of these cemeteries are actually visible from the road, so while you may not get the full effect of ghosthunting them, you may see some strange things. And many people get the same dark feelings during the day as well. The town of Reily is creepy enough after dark; you don’t need to break the law and enter the cemeteries to truly experience the hauntings here.
ROSE HILL CEMETERY
171 South Mason Montgomery Road, Mason, OH 45040
directions
Take I-71 north to the Fields Ertel exit. Turn left onto Mason Montgomery Road. Travel about four and a half miles down the road until you see Rose Hill Cemetery on your left. Once you enter through the main gate, go to your right toward the office. Drive past the office and slightly to your left. The McClung family plot is marked by a large family obelisk covered with names. Rebecca and John’s headstones face the street.
history
John McClung was a very jealous person who would rarely, if ever, let his wife Rebecca out of the house. One day in 1901, a scream was heard from the McClung house. When neighbors rushed to see what had happened, Rebecca lay dead in the bedroom, and John was covered with her blood. She had been beaten to death with a log from the fireplace. Her body was moved to the basement of the house while her plot was prepared, and then she was moved a short distance down the road to Rose Hill Cemetery and the family plot.
John was put on trial for murder. He claimed that he was outside at the barn, but everyone knew that he had killed her. The trial drew headlines, and John was demonized in the media for the brutal murder. Somehow though, he was acquitted of the crime. Further, in 1904, he was buried in the plot directly beside Rebecca, the woman he was accused of brutally murdering. (see McClung House chapter in the Businesses section of this book)
ghost story
Rebecca is seen in the cemetery at night. She is most often seen walking up to her own headstone. She appears to be a real person. She is not misty or a momentary shadow. She appears as a full apparition that looks exactly as Rebecca looked in life. Witnesses will be shown a picture of Rebecca and will swear that it was the same person. When she is approached, she always vanishes suddenly. People suggest that she roams the cemetery at night because she is upset that her murderer and oppressor is buried in the plot directly beside her and that he got away with her murder.
visiting
The McClung plot is very difficult to see from the road at night, and unfortunately, the cemetery closes at dark. This makes it difficult to witness the ghost here since she appears mostly at dark or at dusk. Most of the time, this ghost is spotted at night by caretakers who think there is a woman trespassing after closing time.
Your best bet for legally spotting this ghost is to go to the cemetery and wait near the McClung headstone until dusk. Sometimes she is spotted while the cemetery is still open, but you will probably want to leave as soon as it gets dark so that you are not arrested for trespassing.
SPRING GROVE CEMETERY AND ARBORETUM
4521 Spring Grove Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45232
directions
From downtown Cincinnati, take I-75 North to I-74. Take exit 19 off I-74, the Elmore Street/Spring Grove Avenue exit. At the end of the exit, turn right onto Colerain Avenue. Colerain will dead end into Spring Grove Avenue. Turn left onto Spring Grove Avenue. Follow this road for a little longer than two miles. Spring Grove Cemetery and Arboretum will be on the left. A large gothic gate marks the entrance.
history
Spring Grove is the second-largest cemetery in the country, covering a total of 733 acres. The cemetery was officially chartered in 1845 as the population of Cincinnati began to grow quickly, and many of the existing cemeteries were filling up. The need became even greater in the late 1840s when a cholera epidemic struck the city. Over the years, the cemetery has grown and many of the city’s most important names are buried here.
The cemetery also contains the remains of those involved in some tragic occurrences and unusual demises. A famous Negro League baseball player who was killed by a runaway car while sitting on the front stoop of an apartment building is buried here as well as a judge who was killed in the Mount Auburn incline disaster in 1889. The man whose death sparked the deadly Courthouse Riots in Cincinnati in 1884 is also buried here.
Spring Grove was created by a landscape architect to look like a park. As the years went by, many people came to the cemetery not to visit loved ones but simply to walk through the beautiful landscape, and the grounds were renamed Spring Grove Cemetery and Arboretum.
ghost story
Many ghost stories circulate about Spring Grove. The grounds are vast, and many areas are remote, so you’ll find some places that are quite creepy.
The most famous ghost story involves the grave of an optometrist named C.C. Breuer. The story goes that when Breuer died, he asked that his eyes be removed from his body and placed into a bronze bust that was placed on the grave marker. The eyes in the bust actually do look real. Many people claim that when they walk near this bust, the eyes follow them, as if C.C. Breuer is watching them from beyond the grave. Unfortunately, most of this story isn’t true. The eyes in the bust are made of glass and were chosen by Breuer himself because they closely resembled his own eyes. The fact that the eyes are glass doesn’t explain the fact that they seem to follow people as they walk near the grave.
Skittish people who walk through haunted cemeteries are sometimes concerned that a corpse will reach up from beneath the ground and grab their legs. As terrifying as this sounds, it is almost unheard of that people report phenomena like this happening anywhere. Spring Grove Cemetery is one of those cemeteries, though, that people sometimes report being grabbed. A caretaker was working by himself and suddenly felt something grab his pants leg. He panicked and fled. Later, thinking more rationally about the situation, he returned to the site expecting to find that there was something on which he had caught his pants leg. To his horror, he found nothing in the area that could have caused this feeling.
Throughout the rest of the cemetery, people will report seeing figures that mysteriously disappear. People will hear voices and will be unable to find their source, and people will see strange white wolves that look at the witnesses before running away. These white wolves are thought to be harbingers of bad luck. According to rumors, people who see the wolves will experience some accident or other bad luck soon after their sighting.
visiting
On the one hand, it is unfortunate that this place closes to the public at night. Also, the staff and ownership of the cemetery do not support the rumors that the cemetery is haunted. They will tell you that the cemetery is not haunted, and they are not likely to support any large-scale investigation at any time.
On the other hand, most of the sightings that have been reported take place