Putin's Russia. Группа авторов
reluctant to provide financing due to high inflation rates, plummeting GDP, massive capital outflows and relatively low consumer demand. From 2000 to 2009, due to the gradual adjustment of the key interest rate by the Bank of Russia, bank lending gradually expanded, especially for mortgages and automobile loans. After the financial crisis of 2008–2009, individual household loans grew faster than corporate lending, non-performing household loans surged and credit contracted making it difficult to finance Russia’s technological modernisation.
As of February 2019, 479 commercial banks were operating in Russia including state-controlled banks (directly or indirectly controlled by Russia’s government or the Bank of Russia); foreign-controlled banks; private banks with capital of more than RUB 1 billion; and private banks with capital of less than RUB 1 billion. The number of banks has been steadily declining due to stricter capitalisation requirements and increased domestic M&A activity by banking holding groups. In recent years, the Bank of Russia has stressed culling weak banks, and enhancing market regulation and control. Banks failing to fulfil minimum capitalisation requirements or not complying with the current legislation on banking activities were placed under prudential control. Financial and economic sanctions exacerbated bank insolvencies. The number of banks in Russia almost halved from 2014 to 2018 (Figure 1).
Figure 1:Number of registered credit institutions and their domestic branches in Russia during 2007–2019 (data as on January 1).
Source: Compiled by the author from the Bank of Russia’s statistics available at www.cbr.ru/Eng/statistics/.
In 2017, the federal law “On Banks and Banking Activities” was amended and banks were divided by the total capital into two categories: banks holding a universal license (minimum total capital requirements of more than RUB 1 billion) and banks with a basic license (minimum total capital requirement — RUB 300 million). The amendments, effective January 1, 2018, had a significant impact on the number of players in Russia’s banking industry.
In 2018, 135 banks participated in the banking groups and 47 were bank holding companies. The share of banking groups and bank holding companies in total banking assets was 86.1% and 13.5%, respectively. In December 2018, the top five banks accounted for 60.4% of the banking sector’s assets. Concentration of banking services is high. The Herfindahl–Hirschman Indices (HHI) of banks’ key performance indicators in 2018 were moderate: assets (0.111), loans and other placed funds provided to resident non-financial institutions (0.158), household deposits (0.227) and capital (0.184). However, HHI for loans, deposits and capital have steadily grown from the years 2016 to 2018, pointing to increasing levels of concentration. This is particularly pronounced in the household deposit market, where the total share of the top five banks is 65.2% with Sberbank alone accounting for 46.1%. The share of state-controlled banks in total banking assets also increased from 59.1% in 2017 to 63.1% in 2018 (Bank of Russia, 2018).
Since 2014, the Bank of Russia has published a list of systematically important banks. This list seeks to facilitate market stabilisation. Russia’s government wants to assure banking market participants that there are still reliable banks in the banking system despite continuous license revocations. The selection criteria for banks to be included in the list are stringent. The list included six state-controlled banks (AO “Gazprombank”, PAO “Bank VTB”, PAO “Sberbank”, PAO “Promsvyazbank”, PAO Bank “FK Otkrytie”, AO “Rosselkhozbank”); three foreign banks (AO “UniCredit Bank” (Italy), AO “Raiffeisenbank” [Austria]), PAO “Rosbank” [Societe Generale, France]); and two private banks (AO “Alfa-Bank” and PAO “Moskovskij Kreditnyj Bank”). These 11 systematically important banks comprise of more than 60% of the total banking assets. Systemically important banks are enormously influential.
Geographical disparities in banking service accessibility are conspicuous. As of December 2018, 56.3% of banks are located in Central federal district (276 banks, including 248 located in Moscow City and Moscow Region), followed by Volga (67 banks, 13.7%); North-West (41 banks, 8.4%); Siberian (28 banks, 5.7%), Southern (27 banks, 5.5%); Ural (23 banks, 4.7%); Far Eastern (16 banks, 3.3%) and North-Caucasian (12 banks, 2.4%) federal districts (Bank of Russia, 2019).
The Role of State in the Banking Sector
The scope of state involvement and control in Russia’s banking sector is an enormous echo of the Soviet pattern. The government’s participation in the banking sector takes numerous forms. The main ones are as follows: (1) de jure state banks (2 banks); (2) state banks with full (100%) government ownership (5 banks); (3) state banks with partial (51–99% shares) ownership (12 banks); (4) banks with indirect state ownership (2 banks); (5) banks under temporary state prudential control (9 banks). The second (2) and third (3) categories are also referred as state-controlled banks in the Bank of Russia statistics.
De jure state banks are banks established by federal laws. They include the Bank of Russia (federal law No. 86 “On Central Bank of Russian Federation (Bank of Russia)” and Vneshekonombank (federal law No. 82 “On Development Bank”). State banks with full government ownership include AO “Rosselhozbank” (100% shares belong to the Federal Agency for State Property Management [Rosimuschetsvo]); Russian National Commercial Bank (Rosimuschestvo); AKB “Rossijskij Kapital” (AO “Agency for Mortgage Loans”); AO “MSP Bank” (Federal Corporation on Small and Medium Business Development) and AO “Roseksimbank” (Vneshekonombank). State banks with partial ownership are represented by AO “Globeksbank”, PAO AKB “Svyaz’ Bank”, AO “Vserossijskij bank razvitija”, Orenburgskij Ipotechyj Kommercheskij Bank “Rus”, PAO “VTB”, AK “BARS”, PAO “Sberbank”, AKB “Novikombank”, KBER “Bank Kazani”, AO “Gazprombank”, Khakasskij Municipalnyj Bank and AO “Ruskobank”. RNKO “Narat” and PAO “Kraiinvestbank” are the only two banks with indirect state ownership (shares belong to the state-controlled enterprises). Nine banks are under temporary prudential control by institutions like the Bank of Russia or Deposit Insurance Agency: Bank FK “Otkrytie”, Genbank, TRAST, Promsvyazbank, Avtovazbank, Rost bank, Aziatsko-Tikhookeanskij Bank, Binbank, Fondervis Bank (Edinyj bankovskij portal, 2019).
Federal law No. 86-FZ “On the Central Bank of Russian Federation (Bank of Russia)” established the Bank of Russia, granting it special legal status by Article 75 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation. The goals of the Bank of Russia are managing the ruble and insuring its stability, promoting the development of the Russian banking system, protecting the stability of the national payment system and financial market. The Bank of Russia is an independent special legal institution exclusively authorised to issue currency and regulate its circulation. The Bank of Russia in collaboration with the government of Russia is responsible for monetary policy and is simultaneously a macroregulator (macroprudential control and supervisory function) of the financial market. In 2000s, the Bank of Russia began decreasing its key policy rate. The rate was 7.75% in March 2019 and the current inflation target is 4%. The Bank of Russia was authorised to resolve problems in the banking system (rehabilitation, bailout of insolvent banks) in June 2017 via the specially established Consolidation Fund of the Banking Sector. It can now acquire shares, bonds, assets and liabilities of insolvent banks and resell them to new investors after financial problems have been resolved. The new resolution mechanism seeks to enhance the Bank of Russia’s supervisory control and improves market discipline.
The Bank of Russia is the main shareholder of PAO “Sberbank” (50 + 1% shares), the largest saving state-commercial bank in Russia. Sberbank has a dominant position in Russia’s financial market. In 2017, it had 28.9% share in assets, 32.4% in corporate loans, 40.5% in household loans, 20.9% in corporate deposits, 46.1% in individual deposits and 39.3% in capital. The credit portfolio of Sberbank is composed mostly of individual household loans (32.0%), petroleum and gas industry (8.9%), real estate (7.9%), metallurgy (7.5%), commercial trade (7.2%), food and agricultural industry (5.2%) and machine building and telecommunications (4% each). The top 20 affiliated client groups