Point of Honor. Robert N. Macomber
The grotesque war raging far to the north of them frequently provided a topic of conversation for the soldiers and sailors at the fortress but no actual sense of threat. The real enemy in the Dry Tortugas was the dazzling tropical sun. Its breathtaking heat and blinding glare could make a man slowly go crazy with skin rashes and hallucinations or cause a sunstroke that could kill him outright. Rank or position provided no protection in this place—senior officers and newly enlisted men were struck with egalitarian efficiency.
It was all so cruelly strange to the pasty, white-skinned boys from the Maine or Pennsylvania or New Jersey regiments. They hadn’t joined up for this, had never even imagined a place like this existed. Not long after each man’s arrival he would start to curse the incessant pounding of the sun, and by the time a week had passed he would despise the shadeless coral rock islands and those sadists in Washington who had sent him this godforsaken place. The boy from up north who used to love the warmth of the spring sun was now a man who hated it as his mortal enemy.
“Gawd, how I hate everything about this damned hell-hole! Smell the stink o’ the place. Ya’d think the poor army sods ashore would have better latrines than that. Half-wit fools can’t even get that right!”
Able Seaman Thomas Mason, sweat soaked and grimy, looked over at a privy on the dock a hundred yards away. Frustration vented, he bent down to seize a crate addressed to the army regimental staff ashore and, grunting out additional opinions about the soldiers of the garrison as he lifted, manhandled it to the edge of the gunwale with a crash. Mason lay over the top of it, catching his breath. Slinging a wave of slimy perspiration from a stubbled face, he gazed aft and sneered between gasps. From a gig alongside, a figure in a dark blue uniform had arrived on deck. The brass from the buttons and insignia gleamed in the steaming glare of the sunlight.
“Ah Lordy, Jackson, see what the United States Army in all their glory done sent us now? Will ya look at that little boy back there all dressed up like a officer. Ya know, maybe it’s a girlee by the look o’ him, come ta think on it. Gawd, no wonder they can’t get it done up in Virginia, little boys like that leading the army.”
White, the coxswain standing by the foremast and supervising the unloading detail, heard the comment and quickly silenced Mason, who was supposed to be helping Jackson sway down some gear into the workboat. The captain wanted to weigh anchor in an hour and they didn’t have much time left. And making fun of officers was never a good idea, especially when they might hear it.
“Mason, never you mind the army, it’s the ever lovin’ navy you’re in and the navy that’ll have your hide! Now shut your damned hatch and do your work, and mind that fall tackle there. Jackson, ya poxy idiot, get that damned thing lashed up proper and swayed over!”
With that said, White turned aft and examined the object of Mason’s sarcasm. Shaking his head and smiling, he found himself in silent agreement with Mason’s comment. The officer did look pretty pathetic.
The badly sunburned army second lieutenant who was the unknowing subject of Mason’s assessment looked distinctly uncomfortable as the St. James rolled with slow rhythm in the low swells of the anchorage off the fortress. Hanging onto a nearby shroud for support, the young man appeared to have little military experience and absolutely no confidence. Sweating profusely in his heavy wool formal coat and hat, he stood on the deck of the naval schooner trying to convey, as professionally as he could, a request from his colonel ashore to the captain of the vessel, Lieutenant Peter Wake of the United States Navy. Tanned and wearing a cool white duck cotton shirt and trousers, Wake’s lean frame swayed easily with the deck as he listened to the army officer’s awkward recitation of the message. The blinding sun made the army lieutenant’s eyes squint, accentuating his less than imposing appearance. The naval officer’s face, by contrast, was in the shade of a broad-brimmed straw hat, haggled from an ancient Bahamian weaver woman in a Key West tavern four months earlier. Wake, uncertain whether the lieutenant’s discomfort came from the nature of the request, the roll of the deck, or both, almost felt sorry for him until he thought about what the man—boy really—was asking him to do.
The lieutenant explained that the 52nd New Jersey Artillery, stationed there at Fortress Jefferson in the Dry Tortugas Islands, had managed to lose some of its men. Five of them, to be exact, had evidently decided to take “French leave” and head somewhere, anywhere, other than the notorious Dry Tortugas Islands. Wake stared at the lieutenant for a moment, wondering how you could lose five men out in the middle of nowhere in the Gulf of Mexico, but was distracted by some whispering forward. Around him the crew of the schooner snickered about the army’s problem and were offering ideas as to why the men had left the desolate outpost. The bosun of the schooner, Rork, standing with arms akimbo on the foredeck, soon put an end to their fun by putting them on the windless to heave the anchor rode short. Rork was not in a good mood. The crew knew the look on the bosun’s face too well. Wake returned his gaze to the unfortunate youngster before him.
“How in the world did they leave the islands here?”
“The Colonel thinks they took an old rowing boat that was on the beach at Bird Key. Nobody thought it would float. Thought it was pretty much rotted out, sir. But I guess they somehow patched it up and made it float. Musta’ made a sail too.”
“You say they’ve been gone for three days? Why didn’t your people go after them right away? Well, they’re probably dead by now.”
“Colonel said that he didn’t want nobody else goin’ off in a little boat and gettin’ killed themselves, sir. All we’ve got are the garrison’s small boats. Colonel’s pretty mad about all of this. Said to ask the navy to go over to the Marquesas Islands and see if the boys made it over to there. He really wants those men back, Captain.”
“Very well. Tell him I’ll check those islands for his men. If I find them, we’ll bring them back here for the colonel to deal with as he sees fit. Tell the colonel I don’t think we’ll find his men alive though.”
With that said Wake dismissed the lieutenant, turned and walked aft toward his cabin ladder, glancing at the tall square-framed bosun.
“Rork, get her under way for the Marquesas. The ebb should carry us out of the anchorage a bit. Have the anchor ready in case we need it in a hurry to keep off a reef. I’ll be below for a minute.”
Descending the ladder to the cabin, he listened as Rork roared out to the crew in his deep voice with the Irish brogue.
“Aye aye, sir. All right now, lads, you heard the captain. Turn to and lay on the halyards. With a will, boys! Let’s send ’em up an see what she’ll do.”
In his airless cabin Wake sat at his desk studying the chart of the islands in the Marquesas group. If those men had made it to that archipelago, over forty-five miles away against what little wind there was, then they’d had better luck than most. The Dry Tortugas were surrounded by very dangerous water, filled with bewildering swift currents and uncharted coral reefs. There were many ways for the deserters to die before they made it to the dubious safety of the uninhabited Marquesas Islands. And once they made it there, if they did, there was no fresh water or help. Only mangrove jungle. Those islands were as desolate as the Tortugas.
Wake tried to puzzle out exactly what had made them try it. Didn’t they know the odds? Had they any maritime experience? He remembered when the 52nd New Jersey had arrived two months ago he heard that they were from some place inland in that state and were angry at being assigned to the bleak and barren Fortress Jefferson. Probably the fugitives had no idea of what they were doing. Probably, in fact, they were dead.
His patrol station for the ninety-foot-long St. James included the Tortugas, the Marquesas, and the western Florida Keys. He had been assigned this station for three long months, since April. The year 1864 was over half gone, and Wake was sick of this duty. Beyond the mind-numbing routine of patrolling the area for blockade runners, message relaying between Key West’s Fort Taylor and Fort Jefferson, and the occasional special mission to go to Havana for dispatches, there wasn’t much to do in this patrol area.
Wake sighed and involuntarily touched the scar on the side of his head, a memento from when he had